94 independent reviews for Scotland by railway vacation
Reviews for Scotland by railway vacation
James Knowles review 11 Oct 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Seeing as much of the country as possible in only 7 days2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Just be prepared for the weather so it doesn't slow you down from enjoying the new cities3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I don't know if it did or didn't, but a train is certainly better than a car.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
I loved it and now that I'm home, I'm wishing I were still there.Ann Kalb review 2 Jul 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Orkney2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Bring rain jacket Relax3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
—4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent - surpassed expectationsGloria Lopez Gutierrez review 18 Jun 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The panoramas of the Scottish Highlands.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be sure to include some time in Edinburgh.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, all of the above.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
I was very pleased.Darlene Fitch Stott review 30 May 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
It was all memorable - from beginning to end but I think I would say taking the train as our mode of travel, enabling us to really see the moors and mountains.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack lightly. A few sweaters and long pants will do just fine (for an April visit). Bring a rain jacket also; we only needed ours one day but good to have on hand.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I feel yes, we benefited the local businesses. Traveling by train I hope reduced environmental impacts - I feel it did.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent! Would do this trip again!siegfried goossens review 25 May 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Jacobine train2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
a fabulous restaurant : https://killiecrankiehouse.com3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
yes4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
next time, I will allow for 1 night extra per location. will give more relaxed feeling and hiking options.Wayne Jackson review 18 May 2023
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
It is hard to choose one thing, the accommodation was excellent, all the trains and transfers were on time and well organised. Hosts and drivers were thoughtful and friendly. The meal at Spean Bridge was excellent! We also enjoyed the tour of the aisle of Skye.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Keep your luggage light - under 15kg.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We know we benefited the local community by spending money in the towns and on the tours.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
The vacation met all our expectations and was very enjoyable.Sharon Williams review 26 Oct 2022
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The friendly, helpful people. The scenery and the food.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Make sure you stay two nights in each place and we did extra in Edinburgh and Glasgow as well.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Definitely benefited local people, supported the community and helped families keep their homes and estates. Using the public transport ie: planes and buses helped the environment rather than using a car rental. We learned a lot about conservation of land, forests etc, on the trip.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Wonderful. Had great support all along the way. Great suggestions of things to do and see.Dave Harris review 19 May 2022
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The trip around Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Go when the weather is good!3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We spent a fortune on food, and only used rail transport4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent, but the cold, windy and grey weather took the shine off itPatrick McGinn review 4 May 2022
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The journey from Glasgow to Spean Bridge was so scenic and although long, the time just passed. The Old Pines was lovely and the evening meal exceptional. Fort William to Mallaig on the Jacobite steam train was another beautiful journey. We loved the Isle of Skye and were so lucky with the weather and the full day sightseeing with Donald was a highlight. The View Field hotel was fabulous. Craigatin House in Pitlochry was lovely. All transfers worked well.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Do pre-book any restaurants as many were full.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, in as much as we ate out which benefitted local businesses and we travelled by train which is good for the environment.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
FabulousPatricia Gabris review 25 Apr 2022
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Our time on Isle of Mull was wonderful. It included great scenery, a fantastic wildlife safari and the ability to relax.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be careful planning two long travel days back-to-back. We traveled from Fionnphort to Edinburgh, about eight hours of travel, followed by an international flight the next day.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, all of it. Lodging and tours were operated/owned by small-business people dedicated to minimizing our impact on the environment.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
All lodging, train reservations and tours were as described in the itinerary. The details in the itinerary were complete and allowed us to self-guide easily.Pete Holdcroft review 2 Oct 2022
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Skye was fantastic and the weather was very kind, we thought Viewfield House ticked all the boxes, it was trying to be environmentally friendly, trying to encourage guests to separate recyclable and non recyclable rubbish in rooms, it had multi use shampoo and conditioner in rooms and similar for jam and marmalade at breakfast. Milk was provided in an insulated flask in the bedroom which we though was inspirational - no plastic!! The owners/hosts were charming and came to meet guests at breakfast and were very charming and down to earth and their staff seemed very happy in their work.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Its a full on vacation and you live out of your suitcase. It can involve a lot of walking as you only really have one full day in each place. Book a hotel in Edinburgh before you start and one in Glasgow when you finish the trip. We chose Barony House in Edinburgh which was run by an Australian family, the renovation of the property was superb, breakfast were fantastic and the host Paul was a typical brash Aussie! In Edinburgh ww chose The Alamo which was on the West of the City amongst numerous record and music shops, very bohemian and close to the the University and Free Museums. We preferred Glasgow to Edinburgh so its definitely worth the stop over. Old Pines Hotel is a glorious location, the food is fantastic but we felt very unwelcome at this hotel which is a great shame as it was probably our favourite from food and location perspective, but the staff and owner simply did not want to engage and it is not somewhere we would return to. We found it very impersonal. You definitely need to book restaurants in advance. We did and even then we could only get meals in some locations at 5.30pm. We saw numerous people being turned away from restaurants when they did not have bookings.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We pondered whilst we were away what the environmental criteria were. At Moyness House in Inverness we did not really see any efforts towards environment or conservation - everything was in plastic sachets (milk, sauces, butter, jams, etc.) - and the host told us he bought from Morrisons/Tesco. We are pleased that the trip supported local independent hotels but feel there needs to be stricter criteria around this to qualify what 'green' or 'environmentally friendly' is. We loved our day trip on Skye, but it made us realise what an impact that was having on the area. Everywhere we stopped the car parks were full and we were one of many getting out of the vehicle, walking to the particular landmark, taking photos, and then walking back to the vehicle. A path to and from the landmarks is being eroded away. The guide told us how tourism in Skye had increased massively - this is good for their economy but cannot be good for the environment/landmarks. We appreciate this is the only way to see everything in such a short space of time, so we're not sure what the answer is! Maybe some sort of walking tour, but obviously that wouldn't suit all visitors.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was a very interesting experience, I would be the driver if we had travelled by car and I would therefore have missed a lot of the spectacular scenery on the train especially from Inverness to Kyle of Lochalsh and from Malaig to Fort William. The trains worked very well and we would definitely use this mode of transport again for a vacation. The Jacobite train disappointed a bit, we could not find any officials to guide us, the on board catering looked very tired and the app was the only way to find out about our seating arrangements. The train does not stop on the viaduct so difficult to get photos and no commentary of where we were or what to see. I did a similar journey on the Rocky Mountaineer in Canada where travelers are made to feel very special and there is an open car to stand in and get stunning photos. I suspect in most locations there is only one train a day so departure and arrival is very restricted. Arrival in Pitlochry at 15:20 and Inverness and 15:23 leaves very little time to do anything and John at Moyness House does not receive guests until 4.30pm which we did not know until we arrived on the doorstep and he wasn't in, and left us with a wasted afternoon!Chris Saunders review 22 Jun 2021
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Tour of Isle of Skye with it’s wonderful scenery- quite spectacular.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light. If you’re going in the Summer, keep covered - the midges are out to get you. If Inverness is on you itinerary do eat at the Tiger on the Wall restaurant - fantastic Indian curry house, not at all like the run of the mill kind. Also look around the Botanical Gardens - beautifully laid out and with a great selection of plants, also has a good cafe with a terrace overlooking the gardens.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We used public transport wherever possible and ate locally sourced vegan or vegetarian food.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
For us this has been a unique experience. We travelled up on the Caledonian sleeper and had some relaxing train journeys through beautiful countryside. Our first vacation in the UK for many years and very rewarding.David Lomita review 28 Sep 2021
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Isle of Skye. Part of that was luck as we did a tour with an amazing guide with a good group. And we had a fascinating cab driver for a long ride. Other good parts but that was the most fun.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Don't do it without changing the itinerary. We spent 2 full days in Pitlochry, a town that maybe merited a 4 hour stopover. At another stop the hosts' hospitality was extolled but we arrived during dinner service and were out 16 hours later so we hardly experienced it.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Have no idea4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Good, maybe even very good but the issues mentioned above in question 2, and a colossal, incomprehensibly inept screw-up by British Airways, prevents me from saying great. I'm going to give it 4 stars but 3 1/2 stars would more accurately express our opinionAnne Roberts review 21 Sep 2021
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
All of it was really lovely and the scenery was breathtakingMary Keating review 16 Sep 2021
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The spectacular rail journeys. The two wonderful hotels on Skye and at Spean Bridge. The Skye tour.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
We felt that the time in Inverness was too long and the time on Skye was disappointingly short. One day less in Inverness and one more inb Skye would have made all the difference. Can this be fed back? If you are doing the rail trip the public transport provisions in Pitlochery are few and far between. There are also only limited taxi companies which made doing anything outside of the town difficult.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, All the hotels and the tours were provided by local people. We were very happy with this aspect of the trip.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was a good trip and we enjoyed it. It could have been improved as the comments above suggest.Read the operator's response here:
Thank you very much for your feedback and we will certainly consider your comments in our future vacation planning.
Tracy Ross review 28 Jun 2021
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The Isle of Skye - so beautiful and everyone was so friendly.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack insect repellent and pack for different weather as it can change very quickly.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I think it benefited tourism.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Very good - a good introduction to the Highlands of Scotland.Della Yaroshko review 29 Oct 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Isle of skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
?o à return on the jacobite.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
9 of 0Mary O review 7 Oct 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
It didn’t rain all week!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Bring walking boots3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Train travel is bound to be better than car4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Great. Expensive but worth every penny.Elizabeth Adamson review 3 Oct 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
All the train journeys were memorable but the favorite was the trip from Inverness to Kyle of Lochalsh - weather was beautiful and scenery stunning. All of the accommodations were very good and interesting in their own way and food provided quite delicious - they certainly know where to send their clients. We go to Scotland for the scenery and for us the west coast around Arisaig was memorable partly because of re-living previous vacations in this area. We had a taxi/guide (Laurie Lowrie) who told us much about the history of the area and also stopped by a remote locally known spot where we were able to take photos of the Jacobite steam train on its way to Mallaig - quite an unexpected pleasure!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Take as little luggage as possible. Some of the accommodation involved climbing stairs (no lift) - e.g.The Place, Edinburgh was a climb but very well worth it! Otherwise just trust all the arrangements made by the operator and enjoy a relaxing time - all transfers and accommodation were exactly as described in the information sent to us.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We were pleased to hear that local people were employed in some of the hotels / B&B. Most places provided soap / shampoo / etc in fixed containers so no waste of lots of little plastic bottles. In most cases the meals had been cooked with some local ingredients e.g fish from Mallaig and vegetables grown on the premises.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was every bit as relaxing and interesting as we hoped for. The weather was ideal, which helped enormously, but in most places there were books / games available so even if we had been rained off we would have had something to do! Every one we met was so welcoming and helpful and so the friendliness of the Scots will continue to be remembered.Ralph Lobatto review 29 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
It was all great but the Isle of Skye was memorable.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Avoid the midges season. September was fine.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Local people benefit commercially and going by train probably helped reduce environmental impact.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Ten out of ten.Nancy Fellows review 27 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We enjoyed scenic Isle of Skye and our ride on the Jacobite train.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Add extra days for Inverness and Isle of Skye!3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, particularly in the more rural areas.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
A very good experience!Michael Burt review 27 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
sunset at Ben Nevis2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
book trip round Skye3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
definitely4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
brilliently put togetherCatherine Burns review 25 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We were well taken care of by everyone involved in the West Highland Line to Skye vacation. Loved the Jacobite Steam Train first trip in first class! We had a private tour guide (Peggy) on Skye who said "Where would you like to go?" The lovely B&B on Skye was in a beautiful, peaceful location on the coast. We took a long walk through the farmland and were gifted with a picture perfect rainbow hovering over the coastal lighthouse. Every detail went smoothly.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
We were not aware that this was not a group tour and that we were on our own to find our way. Given this, the operator understood our surprise and because of construction at the Glasgow train station as well as our appearing a bit nervous about getting the right train, they kindly had one of their staff meet us at our Glasgow accommodation and accompany us to the train station to make sure we knew the ropes! We were so grateful. But there was no need to be concerned since every detail was clearly spelled out, we were met at each stop and were well taken care of.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Hard to know, but surely we stayed in locally owned accommodations and our guide on Skye was a local family owned operation. We had meals in the B&B's and shopped in small local shops, visited a small locally owned distillery shop and visited a gallery supporting a Scottish artist.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
We loved every aspect of this vacation and highly recommend this operator. They are wonderful people!Peter and Janet Bennett review 24 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Our trip around the Ilse of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Book with this operator3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Travel by train was excellent Best way to see the environment and better for the environment4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
FantasticChristie Craig review 11 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
How stunningly beautiful Scotland is. Every day was filled with incredible scenery.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Drivers not experienced driving on the left should plan shorter driving days for 3-4 days.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes. The bookings and locations were owned and hosted by lovely local people.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
ExcellentAssaf Yosha review 8 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The hikes we did in the Highlands, food was wonderful at the Bed & Breakfasts2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
As others have said, keep the luggage to a minimum. Makes it easy on the trains. Some trains had reserved seating. Other trains don't (even if your seat number is noted). The operator did a nice job of getting our seats together for a family of four.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Definitely benefited locals with the use of B+B's instead of chain hotels. Use of the train instead of cars decreased the environmental impact. But we still felt the need to rent a care in a couple locations in order to get to some sites.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent!Barb De Wit review 6 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The Isle of Skye day tour2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Book a tour with a professional tour guide. Don't drive through this very busy area yourself in a rented car.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We went on the Isle of Skye tour in a small tour bus that carried seven people. If most people did this, it would reduce the number of private sedans on the road being driven by inexperienced drivers. We were so happy to have a tour guide who lives in highlands. Our tour guide's name was Roderick and he was a highly qualified guide from the local area.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Fantastic! Even better than we imagined!Michael Springford review 6 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Sunrise over the hills above Loch Carron from our bedroom window in the Plockton Hotel; the charm and comfort of the Plockton Hotel; the vast sweeps of open mountainside on Skye; discovering Dornock from the luxury of the The Steadings; the pipe-band and Scottish dancing in the square after dinner in the Courthouse Restaurant in Dornock; the castles of Eileen Donan, Dunrobin, Mey and Urquhart; the small city of Inverness and walks on the Ness islands.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Expect unsettled weather. It rained every day, sometimes heavy and prolonged, accompanied by strong winds.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, but enjoying locally sourced food wherever possible and traveling by train.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Thoroughly enjoyable.Susan Dean review 6 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The people of Scotland. They are wonderful!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
All the arrangements were excellent. Be very clear about what you want and need.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We didn’t drive and took the train. In Mull, especially the people are very concerned about conservation and the environment.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent!Cecille Marsh review 3 Sep 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Jacobite steam train and tour of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel as lightly as possible.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Traveling by train reduced carbon emissions. Accommodation comprised privately owned and family-run establishments employing local people.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Great way to see the Highlands. Very efficiently planned tour.Jan Rimerman review 20 Aug 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The scenery & meeting the people in the B & Bs.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Read Robert's Suggestions & print them out so they are at your fingertips at each location you stay.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We had amazing conversations that revealed more commonalities than differences. We added to the local economy by enjoying the various restaurants and visited the local sights.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Fabulous!!!Hilda Reinauer Stark review 7 Aug 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We enjoyed the whole train experience, Skye was the most interesting and not to miss.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Make it longer stay a few more days in Edinbur and Glasgow 3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental Impacts or supported conservation? By being a conscientious visitor I would say yes, we do not litter or waste willfully4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Great.Sue Huwitt-Dutton review 2 Aug 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The steam train journey travel2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light with clothes that travel well. We lived out of the case which saved a lot of time wasting with packing and unpacking.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes definitely4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
ExcellentUlrika Bjorklund review 7 Jul 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Experiencing the beauty of Scotland. Every destination was different and offered different sites, points of interest. The guest houses were conformable and clean and the owners were very friendly and accommodating. The trip was very well organised with clear instruction on where and when to take the next train connection. Everything worked very well, no problems and no glitches. Appreciated the support and tips from the agent, they are very professional.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
I definitely recommend this trip. It gives you an insight into what Scotland has to offer. As the weather changes from day to day make sure to bring a variety of clothes and pack lightly.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, every guest house promoted sustainability.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent !Barb Cameron review 23 Jun 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We had a driver for a day in Perthshire, Ronnie Owens. He showed us so much and told us so much about the area. Just loved it.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
I would tell them to book the excursions. You just can't see as much on your own. I would suggest to stay a second night at Spean Bridge.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Tourism is a big industry, so I believe it benefited local people. Taking the train and booking group excursions, reduces traffic, which seemed to be considerable at some sights.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Fantastic.Nancy Petersen review 9 Jun 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Jacobite steam train2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Good combination of planned (accommodation, transportation) and free/flexible time.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Benefit to local people (local B&Bs), not so sure on the rest4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
ExcellentChristine Helfrich review 5 Jun 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Isle of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack lightly but bring rain gear3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
A+veronica ward review 2 Jun 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Seeing a lot of different areas in Scotland. Enjoying the history of the country from Edinburgh to Culloden battlefield. Places were clean and the people friendly2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack very light. Casual pants and sturdy shoes for walking. Raincoat with hood. A lot of walking uphill on this trip.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
A great trip. We changed our train to an earlier one in Pitlochry so we could have more time in Inverness to see Cromarty and the Black Isle. Also our direct train to Pitlochry was cancelled and we had to go to Stirling and then to Pitlochry. This was great as we went to the castle.Kent Handel review 30 May 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The whole tour was great, very well organized. We really enjoyed going around the Isle of Skye.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Just do it!3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We would like to believe so.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Well worth doing.David Gannon review 13 May 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The beautiful scenery and the friendly and interesting people you meet.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Think about going early in the year: April and May have the least rain and aren't jam-packed full of tourists. It was cool, but every day started with sunshine.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
The local people running hotels, restaurants and guides certainly benefitted. They also seemed to enjoy their interactions with us. Rail was the primary form of travel on our tour, and it is less environmentally damaging than driving.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was a well designed and excellently organized tour. It exceeded our expectations.Ken Hastings review 11 May 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Touring the Isle of Skye with Roddy MacDonald. Due to the fact it was just me & my wife, Roddy added a very personal touch to the day.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Skip the Jaobite steam train.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Absolutely.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Could not have asked of more from Chris Stewart & McKinlay Kidd.Kok Kuang Hooi review 5 Oct 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Dennis Allen review 5 Oct 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Retracing my journey back in 1970, how things change.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Spend more time in one place, avoid the driving.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Not really.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Overall we enjoyed the highlands as they are spectacular in their beauty.Connie Wightman review 6 Aug 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Rannoch Moor, Staffa2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack light! No luggage room on trains and most small hotels and b&bs don't have elevators or porters3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I think so. Skye was very overrun with tourists and Knoydart town was not prepared for tourists, but all else was very good4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
7 out of 10 and a good valueKaren Schumacher review 25 Jul 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
visiting Isle of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
There are a number of options for tours around the Isle of Skye check them all out.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Alan Dulwich review 11 Jun 2019
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The Isle of Skye with its variety of scenery was the most memorable. The B & B, Craigatin House, at Pitlochry was outstanding - in fact we enjoyed every moment in this town.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Weather plays a big part in the enjoyment of this vacation. Constant rain can make the travel unpleasant.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, all the accommodation we stayed at promoted environmental ideals. However, out in the open air not everybody is so concerned with graffiti and rubbish often in evidence.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was an excellent vacation enhanced by good planning for connections and transfers which made for no stress. Although train seats were reserved, none were available. It was a bit of a free for all when boarding trains.Georgia Marshall review 5 Nov 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
I visited four countries, three were new to me, and the highlight was the wonderful train trip around Scotland. I love trains and where I live in Idaho there are no trains! This trip was organized by a company who is part of Responsible Travel's network. I definitely would use them again if I decide to go to Ireland next year. All the small, locally owned hotels were great, the people were friendly and helpful. Also, we met so many interesting and nice people on the trains.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Again, contact the tour company to help you with booking your hotels, trains, taxis and anything else you need. Let them know what you want to see and do and they will map it all out for you.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Absolutely! The locally owned hotels and B&Bs were so nice and enjoyable. I'm trying to think of any suggestions to improve this trip, but I can't think of a thing.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was exceptional. I've given the name of Responsible Travel to a number of people I met on this trip as a company they should definitely look into before their next adventure. I found Responsible Travel simply by googling "train trips around Scotland." Thank you for such a great time.Tim Hellings review 25 Oct 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Touring Skye by car2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Book as early as possible to ensure getting the best choices of accommodation. Also, beware Caledonian Sleeper and Scotrail unreliable services;3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Only that it all contributed to the local tourist economy. Not sure how it would've benefitted environment or conservation.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent in terms of enjoyability and overall organisation of the packageTerry Bazeley review 26 Sep 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Being able to enjoy the views from the train without having to drive!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack sensible clothes, you need walking boots and waterproofs, but expect you knew that, then enjoy.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes tourism is obviously a big thing and gives employment , also gives a reason to conserve the environment with accessible walks etc.,4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
ExcellentClare Wee review 1 Sep 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
I loved Pitlochry, and the many walks around there.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel Light.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Some of the time. I think more can be done to alert travelers of reducing environmental impacts. E.g. reminders by operators abt the importance of not littering, for e.g.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
I had a splendid time, and though I might do a few things differently next time around, overall, it was a huge success.Leana Moritt review 23 Jul 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Skye was incredible, despite the weather.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
If you are either traveling to/from London or spending time before or after your train excursion exploring the UK, then consider buying a Britrail Pass and asking for a credit for the train part of the fee. We did that and it saved us substantially.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, we were happy to stay at smaller local places (which were excellent) and that, for the most part, were within walking distance of interesteting things to do and see. The hotel all featured sustainable practices.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was wonderful.Holly Manning review 5 Jul 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Isle of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Add another day and night on Skye to allow for a boat trip to one of the nearby islands.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Very specialJan Pollard review 22 Jun 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Half day tour of Skye with Gordon McIntyre from Kyles Taxis2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light with warm layers and a good quality waterproof coat with hoodg3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Local stores definitely benefited.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
John Moug review 14 Jun 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The wonderful accommodation, magnificent scenery and friendly people we met.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Trust the organisers the have everything under control. Use publuc transport in each area to really experience each area.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Generally yes.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
One of my the best vacation experiences we have had. As independent travelers we enjoyed having organised transport and accommodation but still moving independently.Lisa Boner review 3 Jun 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The great way to travel, by train!! So relaxing and we met great people. Then we got to spend time on our own at the different stops. Unlike a bus tour where you must go to specific places and be back at a specific time, we were able to explore the towns on our terms. Accommodations were varied and clean with great service and food. Put all that in the beauty of Scotland and your have the perfect trip!!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pick this trip.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, the bed and breakfast places were all local people, not major chain hotels. They all emphasized water conservation and free trade teas ans coffee.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
One of the best vacations I've had.Anna Cheetham review 29 May 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Great scenery, train trips and wonderful weather.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Don't make your luggage too heavy. We had cases we could manage well but our friends didn't and found it hard to carry their own cases. Book more than one night in the places where you stop off. there are some beautiful walks and places of interest in all the areas we visited.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We had great breakfasts and dinners using local produce. Pines Hotel in Spean Bridge is very environment friendly.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
We thoroughly enjoyed this vacation, much better than we thought it would be. The trains were on time, the hotels and houses we stayed in friendly, clean and good locations. One of the best vacations we have had in Scotland.Belinda Bremner review 19 May 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Impossible to say. Each stop was unique2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
I would reinforce that one should be flexible, expect a wide range of experiences and weather. Pack very lightly but layer. Do your homework.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes. All hotels and guide were local4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
ExcellentPatricia Clark review 29 Sep 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Haggis2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack light. There is so much moving around with your suit case yes3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
8/10Stephanie Zimmermann review 14 Sep 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Too many things to list! The overall beauty of Scotland was awesome. The Isle of Skye hotel had a great restaurant and pub. The Blair Athol Castle in Pitlochry was really special. We rode the bus from our hotel; which was easy, economical and efficient.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light. Also, be aware that train seating can be a little confusing. It was challenging, at times, to find the right car.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes. The food was farm to table. Riding trains reduces the carbon footprint.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
This was a really fun and interesting journey that I would recommend to others. There’s so much beauty in Scotland that you can see on this trip. I give it 4 Stars only because the train seating was confusing.Jerry Shields review 15 Jun 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The people of Scotland were warm and welcoming which surprised us a bit. The land is beautiful in its own way and well worth a tour but not the most scenic we have visited.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Really do not recommend the Scottish rail system. No one pays any attention to the idea some travelers have reserved seats and locals just take any seat seat reserved or not. There is a critical lack of storage space for luggage of any size. It is difficult to determine what car you should be in and always having to ask people to vacate your seat is uncomfortable.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Hard to say but we were very impressed with their efforts to to recycle waste and the country sides were free of litter. We did our best to leave no trace.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was well organized but the written dialogue could have been better and warnings about train travel in Scotland would have you better prepared for its rigors. Glad we made the trip but would do it differently next time.Donna Fahey review 14 May 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The train ride from Inverness to Glasgow2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light, You have to carry your bag on and off the trains.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
It benefited local people since we stayed in bed and breakfasts most of the time. It reduced environmental impacts because we didn’t have to rent a car.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
We liked it a lot. The breakfasts were delicious, the service was great and taxis and trains were always on time.Julia Kitchen review 26 Apr 2018
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Time on the Isle of Skye - it is a very special place2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light, visit Culloden, ask for window seat on the Jacobite Express3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Benefited in the sense of revenue generation for local people. Train travel not car4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Great and well-organised by the tour operator.Bruce Bogue review 15 Oct 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Staying in 200+ year-old homes, which have been meticulously maintained.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Spend at least 3 nights in each location to experience at least 2 full days.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I don't believe that we did anything that could have harmed the environment, and enjoyed pubs, theaters, restaurants, tours and shops whenever possible.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent...so much more than we even expected.Ken Yeager review 14 Oct 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Tour of Isle of Skye2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Plan for changing weather and bring clothes (layers) for all occasions.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
No4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Great trip. Loved Scotland and its people.Read the operator's response here:
Many thanks for your comments. We are delighted you enjoyed the trip. We pride ourselves on building long-term relationships with locally owned businesses, for accommodation, taxis and guides, to ensure that the benefits of tourism are enjoyed directly in the local area. This helps to create a sustainable economy in remote rural places with positive impact on the community.
Amanda Wright review 9 Oct 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Skye is stunning and the trip on the Jacobite Express was a lovely afternoon.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Try to travel as light as possible since luggage allowances are not generous on most Scotrail trains. At any time of year layers are advisable when traveling in Scotland as the weather can be unpredictable. Sturdy footwear is advisable if you want to do any walking in Skye as even main paths can become very muddy after rain.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I did feel that my trip benefited the local economy and it was good to be able to travel to some of the more rural locations on the trip without being dependent upon a car to do so.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was an excellent vacation. The accomodation was cosy and comfortable and pleasantly diverse. Food was great, scenery beautiful as always, and I met a great many like minded people during the course of this trip from all over the world.Mary Ann Bindbeutel review 25 Sep 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Skye was simply beautiful. My favorite spot the Fairy Glenn. Of course as always it is really the people you meet that make the journey, Scotland did not disappoint. Everyone was exceedingly friendly, helpful and a delight.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Book restaurant reservations before you leave home. The restaurants are small and when booked you could be out of luck. The hotel staff was helpful with late bookings.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Definitely benefited local people at least those in the tourist industry.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was wonderful.John Downham review 18 Sep 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Wonderful scenery.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Organise your time in each venue to make the most of your stay3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Organisation was impeccable. All ran very smoothly but we would have liked longer in each venue.Donald Ross review 2 Aug 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Visit to the Isle of Skye where my ancestors came from, and our stay at Kinloch Lodge there, with outstanding food prepared by their chef.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Traveling around by train is a great way to go. You're free to take in the scenery without concentrating on your driving, and you get to meet local people on the trains.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes. Most of our meals were locally-sourced.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
One of our very top favorites, and we've done a lot of traveling in Europe.Steven Daish review 26 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The scenery and the stunning views.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Wrap up warm3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes it manages to keep the local communities funded via tourism.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
An excellent trip - thanks!!Patrick IRLINGER review 21 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Jacobite steam train, Skye Island, Loch Ness and Uquhart Castle,2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
If you do a train tour, try to travel in the late afternoon instead of the middle of the day.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, local people were very friendly and helpful.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was an excellent stay. Beautiful landscapes, Scots charming, good quality of restaurants and guest houses. Not or few traffic jams in Glasgow and Edinburgh.Judith Innamorato review 13 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The remarkable scenery and natural beauty of the highlands, the kind and welcoming hosts at all our accommodations.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be patient with the weather. It truly changes moment by moment.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, all the accommodations were in natural setiings. We often ate farm to table. Using rail travel is more eco friendly than renting a car and driving.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Our vacation was exceptional, we enjoyed every aspect of the trip and the effortless planning was most enjoyable.Maren Child review 10 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The Jacobite Express was terrific and we had really good seats. The pub at our accommodation in Skye was great fun and good food. Best meals at Killiecrankie Hotel.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
The app was great, allowed us to see all our arrangements and bookings offline. The printed map of UK railway routes was great, as I couldn't see railway tracks on Google maps. Inverness on a Sunday is very quiet - would be better to be there during the week. McKinley Kidd were very well organised. Some of the accommodation was not near any public transport so it was not possible to go to the recommended activities or eat in town. However the meals at all accommodation were excellent.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
All transport was by train or local taxis, buses and a local tour guide.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
A good variety in types of accommodation, all very well organised and quite luxurious. The train travel was very relaxing.Alison Sawyer review 23 Oct 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Our private tour of the Isle of Skye.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be sure you're ok with moving luggage and yourselves frequently. Also, try to get more information on accommodations before booking the trip.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Definitely.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Good way to see a lot of Scotland without driving.Susan Telfer review 1 Oct 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Our vacation was well planned and ran very smoothly. The accommodation was of really good quality and we most enjoyed our visit to Pitlochry and Glasgow.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
We would recommend this type of vacation for people who like independent travel3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Not particularly4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
We enjoyed the vacation and would recommend it to othersCaroline Heathcote review 20 Sep 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Train travel is so relaxing although it does perhaps preclude some of those unplanned and impetuous detours!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Plan ahead for what you want to do at the various stops which are really brief and don't be scared to use local transport.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Perhaps although not immediately evident - too many Scots appeared to be absent; perhaps it's due to low unemployment but far and away the majority of people we came across were neither Scottish or British.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was really a great week - the various hotels ranged from wonderful top-class to something less so, but all the arrangements worked so well.Peter Bates review 3 Aug 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We enjoyed all of the vacation, no outstanding part. Isle of Sky was probable the most memorable, unfortunately the weather was most memorable part, being wet every day, apart from one day in Pitlochry. The last property at Spean Bridge was the most enjoyed.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Being prepared to live out of your case.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
The benefit to local people must be income received from dinning expenditure and any other items of expenditure. It could be argued that environmental and conservation was effected by the extra people being present.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
The vacation was different to other forms of vacationing, we are the wrong age for such a vacation.Elizabeth Winney review 4 Jul 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Most enjoyable part was our two days on Isle of Skye. Very beautiful and dramatic scenery!2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Pack light for all the carrying of luggage on and off trains.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes. Good to make use of public transport! Standard of trains in Scotland very poor in terms of cleanliness but they did run to schedule and the scenery is spectacular.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Very enjoyable!Roger North review 28 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Breakfasts, some of the greetings we got and the dinner on the last night. Add to that some fantastic scenery and the stream train.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
With a couple, travel with two small suitcases and be aware that there can be quite some walking.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Local people were usually our hosts, traveling by train was better than us doing it by car and I hope visitors to some of the areas, like Culloden, helped to ensure preservation and good use of beauty spots.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Very enjoyable, it was excellent and exiting, a tad expensive. Sadly the most expensive hotel on Skye, for which we had to pay a supplement, was the least best with very expensive food of not excellent quality, the bar food was in a shabby bar and twice the price it should have been. At breakfast an extra piece of bacon, after the one served, cost £1.50 ! The rooms were soulless and uncared for, though clean, lots of climbing stairs, bedroom upstairs, loo downstairs. But it was a stunning view.Derrick Horne review 2 Jun 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
it's very hard to choose but probably the steam journey to Fort William and the and the final days journey over Rannock Moor the whole vacation lived up to our expectations2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
travel lightly and keep your eyes open3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
yes - it was encouraging and also surprising to see so many touriats on the Isle of Skye4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
First class with perhaps one serious reservation which involves the Portree Hotel on Skye - this fell short of the standards set during the rest of our vacation - first our initial greeting was not the best with the receptionist more interested in talking and laughing with her friends that dealing with a new arrival - and perhaps much more serious was the location of our room on the third floor --- the room itself was fine with views of the square but the journey there from reception wa difficult -- there was no lift in the hotel and the stairs were very long and steep - impossible I would say for anyone who was even slightly disabled also I have to say there was an air of casualness about the hotel extending to the breakfast area where the service was not always the best - and on one occasion my partners fish breakfast of haddock was very disappointing sadly this experience reduces the overall rating to four star - otherwise a strong fiveMarie Isabelle Cremers Tavares review 13 May 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Isle of Skye and Viewfield House2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Avoid Craigatin House, owners un-friendly3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Well organised, interesting places choosen, lovely hotels (even Craigain House was lovely, the welcome there was less so)Carol Hartnett review 7 May 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Traveling by train thorough the moors and mountains of Scotland in the comfort of the train.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Recommend planning two days at each stop and booking ahead local sightseeing as local bus service not always available.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, we traveled by rail which reduced carbon,stayed in local bed and breakfasts, and used local tours and transport all of which employed locals. Many of the activities we took part in involved hiking or walking in local areas which supported conservation.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
We travel extensively and this rated as one of our top 3 vacations.Arthur Bleasdale review 31 Mar 2017
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Walking up to the Old Man of Storr. Amazing views2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be equipped for weather of all sorts3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Must have helped employment. Traveling by train reduced environmental impact.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Top classApril Maxwell review 21 Sep 2016
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The entire trip was absolutely breath-taking and well planned. The highlight was Killiecrankie, beautiful scenery and magnificent food.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Book the extra excursions, they are well worth it.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Absolutely, the accommodations were well-chosen and not chain hotels, local people benefitted from tourism trade, and environmentally better by utilising mass transportation rather than individual car hires.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
10 out of 10Bruce Hemingway review 28 Jul 2016
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
To much to tell really, everything went to your arrangements made for me. All the accomadation was excellent, The Pines certainly didn't expect that, also Hotelat Pitochry the meals you could not fault them. All as said were great. The Pitochry is 3 miles from town which certainly did not bother me at all Thanks for the great time I have had.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Don't know really it all went so smoothly, there are options at each place for sightseeing which I did in every place.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes it is a benefit to them money for one which we all need. Everywhere travelled it was always clean know rubbish around which is great to see.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent enjoyed every minute so keep up the great service to visitors to your country.Doris Burke review 21 May 2016
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Not having to drive! It was actually freeing to not have to worry about renting a car, finding our way in a foreign land, etc. The trains were comfortable and a great way to travel about.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
As all trips, we would've like more time in each of the locations - but especially in Edinborough and Pitlochry.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes, very much. All of our accommodations were in locally owned, historic properties with attentive hosts who were happy to share stories of their establishments with us and make recommendations for local shopping and restaurants.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
This was a first-class tour which is very well thought out and planned.Carol Evans review 23 Sep 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The Jacobite Express and the Killiecrankie Hotel2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be prepared to be delightfully surprised.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Taking the train was economical and local people owned and managed our accommodation. And we tasted lots of local whisky!4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent. We loved everything about it except that it was over too soon!Kathy McLeod review 27 Sep 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The entire experience, although having the opportunity to visit my husband's ancestral home on Isle of Skye was a definite highlight.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
The trip was very well planned, complete with pre-booked reserved seats on the trains. Travelers should make sure they understand the Scottish rail's reservation system. We had some confusion on our first leg, but were able to sort it out afterwards.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent. Accommodations, hosts, meals, and travel arrangements all exceeded our expectations.Dimity Lawrence review 7 Sep 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The opportunity to have assistance to plan a trip suited to our desires, time constraints, budget.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Be guided by the trip plans on offer, as well as the knowledgeable staff members, but don't be afraid to ask for exactly what you want because the vacation providers staff are so helpful, flexible and obliging.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes ... Local communities benefit from tourism and train travel benefits the environment.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent ... so easy, comfortable and enjoyable.Alan Warr review 12 Jul 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Exciting was the steam train to Mallaig made very enjoyable as we were First Class. Memorable was the welcome, comfort and quality of the service and food at the Killiecrankie Hotel.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Travel light as there is not much room for luggage on the trains3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Bringing income into the areas of Scotland supported local businesses. Traveling by local transport reduced the environmental impact.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Very good indeed. In general and excellent vacation and a good way to see ScotlandLynn Furness review 27 Jun 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
1) Staying at the beautiful "Old Pines" guest house at Spean Bridge overlooking snowcapped Ben Nevis 2) Traveling on the Jacobite Steam Train. 3)The beauty of the Scottish countryside particularly on the Isle of Skye & the very hospitable taxi owners Peggy & her husband there. 4) Seeing a red squirrel at Killacrankie.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
1) Travel light (as there is not much room for luggage on the trains, & much carrying of luggage on and off trains & up stairs in accommodation (although most hosts were helpful in this regard. 2) If you have mobility difficulties you need to notify hotel hosts as only some accommodation has down stairs rooms.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Yes very much4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
It was very enjoyable and I recommend it for train enthusiasts. Although accommodation places were first class (comfortable good food etc & excellent views etc we would have preferred accommodation on Skye in walking distance to Armadale one closer to the township of Pitlochary of Pitlocary.Valerie Deunk review 24 Jun 2015
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
We could not decide - the friendly people we encountered everywhere, the lovely accomodation booked for us, some of which also had fine dining for evening meals, the ease of train travel in Scotland, the rental car and the fun of driving for the first time on the other side of the road on Isle of Skye, and finally the amazingly beautiful vistas in the Highlands. Like "heaven on earth" - I had always dreamed of visiting Scotland but no photo can do justice to the beauty of the green hills, rugged mountains and the livestock everywhere. Tiny tea houses, scones, seafood, lamb, beef, beer and wine. Sampling Scotch Whiskey and Haggas... We loved it all.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
We were thankful that we just had carry-on luggage for ease of hopping off and on trains and buses. Layers of clothing are needed to accomodate to the changing weather - we were told and do believe that there is no bad weather in Scotland, just bad wardrobe choices!! Save shopping for large wouvenirs til the end of the tour, or have items (such as pottery from Uig on Isle of Skye) shipped.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We were aware that the Scotland in general and certainly smaller centers rely on tourism to maintain their grand old manor houses and castles. We saw evidence of efforts to be "green" throughout - both in the city and moreso out in the countryside.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Cant' say enough about how much we appreciated the arrangements made for us by the operator - to be able to see so much of the country and yet enjoy a wonderful stress-free vacation - Simply ONE OF THE BEST vacations that I have every been on...I will give 4 stars only because I have had some lovely vacations in Africa and in Europe with my family - each one was the best !! But trip was much more enjoyable than I could have dreamed of.Anthony Watts review 28 Sep 2014
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
The way everything that was listed in the very detailed itinerary happened exactly as stated.2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Try to travel as light as possible3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
We stayed at several hotels and guest houses also went on 4 excursions so all these benefitted local people. All travel was by train so apart from transfers from train to accommodation and back our environmental impact was very low.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
A wonderful experienceMichael Rose review 8 Jul 2014
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Train journeys and particularly the West Highland Line. Enjoyed the drive round Skye though would have preferred to hire a car (too old at 77 according to the three companies we tried)2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Spend more time on Skye and possibly Spean Bridge or wherever a person's interests show more to see. We were not just traveling for the train journeys.3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
Jobs to locals, saved cars on the roads etc4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent.Joy Wessels review 18 Jun 2014
1. What was the most memorable or exciting part of your vacation?
Possibly our stay at Killiecrankie Hotel, although whole experience was memorable2. What tips would you give other travelers booking this vacation?
Make sure you book the taxi driver for a half day tour in Skye, the bus service is very erratic !3. Did you feel that your vacation benefited local people, reduced environmental impacts or supported conservation?
I hope so, traveling by train and local buses instead of by car when able makes far more sense.4. Finally, how would you rate your vacation overall?
Excellent vacation with wonderful hotels and superb organization, the sun followed us around Scotland ! Only very slight comment would be on the restaurant menu in Skye which is both very expensive and limited, but the pub is good !!Staff in Skye need to take lessons from the wonderful service elsewhere, particularly @killiecrankie hotel where we were met after an evening at the theatre with an umbrella and kept bar open for us to have a drink to take to the bedroom to watch the Workd Cup !Holiday Reviews
You can trust Responsible Travel reviews because, unlike many other schemes, reviews can ONLY be written by people who we have verified have been on the holidays. In addition, we don't run these holidays ourselves - our only interest is giving you the best independent advice.
